All buyer's guides
Payment Platforms · Buyer's guide

Square vs Stripe vs PayPal vs Authorize.net: which should you pick?

A side-by-side look at price, features, quality and value across the leading payment platforms options — so you can choose the right one in minutes.

Visit squareup.com
The verdict
Editor's pick
Square

Best POS hardware

Best value
Square

Lowest entry price among the options compared here.

Best for power users
Stripe

Online API less robust

Feature & price comparison
Feature
Squarefeatured
Payment Platforms
Stripe
Alternative
PayPal
Alternative
Authorize.net
Alternative
Processing
2.6% + $0.10 in-person
2.9% + $0.30 online
2.99% + $0.49 online
2.9% + $0.30 + gateway
POS
Best — full hardware
Stripe Terminal (BYOD)
PayPal Zettle
None
Ecom
Strong Square Online
Native + 200+ plugins
Universal carts
Gateway only
Devs
Solid REST
Industry-leading
Decent
Legacy XML/REST
Intl
US/CA/UK/AU/JP/IE
135+ currencies
200+ markets
US + Canada
Why shoppers pick Square
  • Best POS hardware
  • Strong in-person
  • Free Square Online
When to consider an alternative
  • Online API less robust
  • Limited international
The short answer

Square is a payment platforms option built for smb retail + food. Shoppers pick it for best pos hardware, but it's worth comparing against Stripe, PayPal, Authorize.net if online api less robust.

Which one should you pick?
Pick if…
Square

Best POS hardware.

Pick if…
Stripe

Consider as the leading alternative to Square in this category.

Pick if…
PayPal

Consider as the leading alternative to Square in this category.

Pick if…
Authorize.net

Consider as the leading alternative to Square in this category.

How to choose
Match the tool to your scale

Square is positioned for in-person retailers. If your team or volume is materially larger or smaller, one of Stripe / PayPal / Authorize.net may be cheaper or more capable.

Pilot before committing

None of these have a true free tier. Ask for a trial or month-to-month billing first, and verify the must-have feature in your own workflow before annual commitment.

Compare total cost, not sticker price

Look past the headline price: add seats, add-ons, integration fees and transaction fees. The cheapest option rarely stays cheapest at scale.

Stress-test the weakness

Known trade-off with Square: Online API less robust. Confirm it isn't a deal-breaker for your specific use case before signing.

What to watch out for
  • Online API less robust
    Confirm this isn't a deal-breaker for your team before signing — it's the most common reason shoppers switch from Square to Stripe.
  • Limited international
    Confirm this isn't a deal-breaker for your team before signing — it's the most common reason shoppers switch from Square to Stripe.
Frequently asked
Is Square worth it in 2026?

For in-person retailers, yes — Best POS hardware. For very different use cases, compare against Stripe, PayPal, Authorize.net.

How much does Square cost?

Square pricing: 2.6% + $0.10 in-person. Always confirm current pricing on the provider's site.

What's the biggest downside of Square?

Online API less robust. Most teams work around it, but verify it isn't a deal-breaker for you first.

Square vs Stripe — which should I pick?

Pick Square if you want best pos hardware. Pick Stripe if you need a broader / cheaper / more established alternative — see the comparison table above for the side-by-side.

More buyer's guides in Payment Platforms

Ready to try Square?

See current pricing and plans on their site.

Visit Square